top of page
Cosmic Cookie Butter

BAKED FROM SCRATCH,

WITH LOVE, &

ALL HAND-STIRRED

HOME TOWN FAVORITES & NEW COOKIES WEEKLY

Baked from the heart in the heart of the Villages, Florida, and enjoyed around the world. Our wide selection of soft and gooey goodies have become an icon in the Sunshine State for a reason. With a selection of over 100 rotating flavors, providing a pallet for everyone. We make every cookie by hand every day, with simple natural ingredients that are scrumptious for the mind, body, and soul.

We bake fresh and ship next-day, so your cookies arrive deliciously soft and chewy for your enjoyment.

Award Winning

Wide Selection Of Flavors

Baked To Order

Top of store
Sugar Free Chocolate Chip

Sugar Free Chocolate Chip

Guilt-free delight with rich dark chocolate morsels, tender chewiness, and no added sugar.

Oatmeal Raisinette

Oatmeal Raisinette

Wholesome blend of hearty oats and plump raisins for a chewy and naturally sweet treat.

Lemon Crinkle

Lemon Crinkle

Refreshing citrus-infused cookie with a soft, dusted in powdered sugar for a zesty burst.

Snickerdoodle

Snickerdoodle

Classic cinnamon-sugar coated cookie with a soft and chewy texture, evoking warmth and nostalgia.

Mexican Wedding Cookie

Mexican Wedding Cookie

Delicate, crumbly treat with buttery richness and powdered sugar, perfect for celebrations and special occasions.

Mango Cloud

Mango Cloud

Tropical delight featuring luscious mango flavor, light and airy texture, leaving a sweet taste of summer.

Chocolate Chip

Chocolate Chip

Beloved classic with gooey chocolate morsels, soft buttery dough, and timeless appeal for all ages.

Chunky Peanut Butter

Chunky Peanut Butter

Nutty delight with generous peanut chunks, offering a satisfying crunch and creamy peanut butter flavor.

Coconut Cluster

Coconut Cluster

Tropical pleasure with shredded coconut, crisp-chewy texture, and a sweet, nutty taste for a beachside experience

Golden Apple Glaze

Golden Apple Glaze

Divine treat with buttery cookie dough, golden apple glaze, and a touch of fruity tanginess.

Red Rooster Cookie Jar Background

Baker's Dozen (Delivery & Pickup Only)

00021
$15.00
Select What Cookies You Would Like In Your Box!
In stock
1
Product Details

Create a custom order consisting of any of our 11 Flagship Flavors. If you can't decide, select assorted flavors to receive a mystery box of goodies.


Select 2,3, or more that you really have your eye on, or select them all for a mixed order of goodies! What ever options you select, we will evenly distribute the quantity of cookies ordered so you have an equal amount of your selections.


Our Bakers Dozen consists of 13 cookies wrapped and neatly packaged within our red cookie handle box


*Naturally Gluten Free - No gluten added or included in this recipe, but is baked in a kitchen where gluten is present.

Save this product for later
bottom of page