
Welcome to Red Rooster Cookie Jar Bakery
Online Ordering
You can place an order online for a future pick up. You can order a delivery for yourself, or if you are from out of town, we can deliver to someone else for you. If you need something sooner, than two days, then please give us a call at 352-204-0201 so we can see how we can help you. Also, feel free to stop into our bakery to pick out your goodies. We can put together a baker's dozen box, a two dozen box or less for you. We do prefer that trays of cookies be ordered ahead of time.
Pick Up/Delivery Menu
ALL ORDERS CAN ONLY BE PICKED UP AT 107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD. OR DELIVERED.
CAKES & PIES
PIES MUST HAVE A 3 DAY LEAD TIME AND CAKES NEED A 2 DAY LEAD TIME, ESPECIALLY BUTTER CAKE
Nana's Italian Almond Ricotta cake
A lighter version of a NY style cheesecake this is my Nana's recipe for a traditional almond Italian cheesecake. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$35.00

Fruit Filled Italian Ricotta Cake
The same as our Nana's Italian, but instead of almond we add a fruit swirl and more fruit on the top. Baked to order. Must be ordered at least 3 days in advance
$40.00

Loaf cake
We have many different flavors that we add often, however you can choose from our usual flavors. If making a special request, please remember that sometimes items are seasonal due to ingredient availability. Also, we must have at least 3 days in order to bake your special request due to our order schedule. Check our TODAY'S FRESH BAKES page to see what flavors we currently have available.
$9.50

Butter Cake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 2 DAY LEAD TIME. Missouri Ooey Gooey Butter Cake that is simply to die for! The bottom layer is a cross between a biscuit and a cookie. It needs to be able to handle the top gooey layer of butter and cream cheese then double dusted in powdered sugar!
$27.00

Crumb Cake
$14.00

Amish Dutch Apple Cake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. A beautifully moist and flavorful cake baked with 9 cinnamon apples and dusted with powdered sugar and drizzled in caramel!
$15.00

Chocolate Torte
MUST HAVE AT LEAST TWO DAY LEAD TIME. A flourless chocolate cake that is a gluten-free friendly option for anyone choosing to limit their gluten intake, but still want to enjoy sweet treats
$17.00

Chocolate Snack Cake
$14.00

Sugar Crunch Cakes
$27.00

Key Lime Pie
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a traditional graham cracker crust and the key lime custard pie, we add a special touch, an extra layer of key lime mousse! Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$30.00

Pie - whole
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Choose from one of our 9" pies baked with homemade from scratch crust just like Grandma used to make. Must be ordered at least 3 days in advance
$30.00

Cannoli Pie
MUST HAVE 2 DAY LEAD TIME
$30.00

BREADS
PLEASE CALL OR CHECK TODAY'S FRESH BAKES TO SEE WHAT FLAVORS OF SOURDOUGH WE STILL HAVE IN STORE
Spinach Feta Bread
Milk, flour, butter, fresh baby spinach, and feta crumbles! That's it!
$12.00

Pepperoni Mozz. Bread
Milk, flour, pepperoni & mozzarella cheese and butter! That's it!
$13.00

Bacon Cheddar Bread
Milk, flour, Bacon and cheddar cheese! That's it!
$12.00

Ham & Swiss bread
Milk, flour, ham, Swiss, & butter! That's it!
$13.00

English Muffin Bread
Tastes just like an English muffin but this one you can slice for toasting or making a sandwich.
$8.00

Sourdough
check Today's Fresh Bakes for available flavors
$7.00

BREAKFAST & PASTRIES
Scones
Perfectly baked and not dry or crumbly. Check our TODAY'S FRESH BAKES page to see what flavors we currently have available.
$3.75

Muffins
Fluffy Bakery Jumbo style muffins. Check our TODAY'S FRESH BAKES page for the flavors we are offering. We try to have 3 different flavors at a time.
$3.75

Biscotti
(2 for...) check with us each week as we bake different flavors often to mix it up.
$4.50

Brownies
sometimes we add mini chocolate chips to the top
$3.50

Turnovers
We have a variety of flavors, and we usually offer 3 different at a time. Call us to see if we have any. Each one is handcrafted with our own filling mixtures.
$5.00

Danish
flaky puff pastry baked with a creamy cheese center and drizzled in a vanilla glaze 5 x 13'
$12.00
Pumpkin Roll
$9.50

CHEESECAKES
ALL CHEESECAKES MUST BE PREORDERED WITH AT LEAST A 3 DAY LEAD TIME.
Plain Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Comes with traditional graham cracker crust unless you would like our signature cookie crust. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$47.00

Cheesecake with fruit
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with our signature cookie crust and topped with a fruit of your choice. We can also add fruit to the inside of the cheesecake and flavor the cheesecake as well. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$52.00

Peanut Butter Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. A Nutter Butter cookie crust with a peanut butter cheesecake topped with a peanut butter ganache and crushed Nutter Butter cookies. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance
$57.00

Baileys' Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with our Signature cookie crust and Baileys' baked into the cheesecake and topped with a Baileys' glaze and crushed .Biscoff cookies. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$60.00

Pumpkin Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a Biscoff cookie crust, a pumpkin cheesecake and topped with whipped cream and more crushed Biscoff cookie crumbs! Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$52.00

Cheesecake slices
Every week we try to offer 1-2 flavors of our cheesecake slices. If ordering online be aware that if you don't call to find out what we have, you may not get the flavor you want.
$6.50

GIFT BOXES & TRAYS
Baker's dozen box
13 cookies of your choosing
$15.50

two dozen box
24 cookies of your choosing or choose assorted and let us give you a wide variety of cookies.
$28.00

Pastry Platter
20 items of your choosing all beautifully decorated on one platter. It makes a wonderful gift for the holidays, birthday, anniversary, even a memorial service. Please remember that the flavors of your items must coincide with flavor availability.
$75.00

Extra Large Tray
5 dozen cookies of your choice
$65.00

Large Tray
4 dozen cookies of your choice
$55.00

Medium Tray
3 dozen cookies of your choice
$45.00

Dog Cookies
Choose between our two flavors of Fur baby cookies. Both are extremely healthy with no preservatives. So clean people can eat them
$2.00

CINNAMON ROLLS - SATURDAY ONLY
PLAIN CARAMEL PECAN

CINNAMON ROLL SATURDAY
SOFT, FLUFFY CINNAMON ROLLS TOPPED WITH CREAM CHEESE BUTTER ICING AND EITHER CINNAMON ROLL YUM CRUMBS OR CARAMEL & PECANS
PLAIN
$5.00

CARAMEL PECAN
$5.00

Thanksgiving Pre-Order: Pick-ups will be 11/23-11/25
October 1st - November 20th. However, depending on how many pre-orders we receive, we might need to close the menu early. THERE WILL BE NO DELIVERY SERVICES 11/23 - 11/25

Pies
All pies made from scratch including the crust. Excellence takes time. All pies need at least 3 days lead time.
Apple Pie
$30.00

Pumpkin Pie
$30.00

Chocolate Pie
$30.00

Cannoli Pie
MUST HAVE 2 DAY LEAD TIME
$30.00

Key Lime Pie
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a traditional graham cracker crust and the key lime custard pie, we add a special touch, an extra layer of key lime mousse! Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$30.00

Blueberry Pie
$30.00

Cherry Pie
$30.00


Cheescakes
Pumpkin Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a Biscoff cookie crust, a pumpkin cheesecake and topped with whipped cream and more crushed Biscoff cookie crumbs! Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$52.00

Baileys' Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with our Signature cookie crust and Baileys' baked into the cheesecake and topped with a Baileys' glaze and crushed .Biscoff cookies. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$60.00

Cheesecake with fruit
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with our signature cookie crust and topped with a fruit of your choice. We can also add fruit to the inside of the cheesecake and flavor the cheesecake as well. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$52.00

Spiced Apple Cider Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a gingersnap crumb crust and Vermont Boiled Apple Cider, topped with more cookie crumbs and whipped cream. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$55.00

Caramel Apple Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a graham cracker crust, topped with apple pie filling and drizzled in caramel sauce. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$55.00

Maple Bourbon Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with an Animal Cracker crust, chocolate maple bourbon cream and a light drizzle of spice-infused maple syrup. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$60.00

Amaretto Almond Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a chocolate cookie crust, Amaretto, and topped with slivered almonds. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$60.00


Cakes
Amish Dutch Apple Cake
9x13 cake covered in cinnamon apples
$30.00

Pumpkin Crumb Cake
A perfectly spiced pumpkin cake covered in a slightly crunchy thick crumb topping, perfect for any holiday table. 9x13
$27.00

Cinnamon Crumb Cake
$27.00

Butter Cake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 2 DAY LEAD TIME. Missouri Ooey Gooey Butter Cake that is simply to die for! The bottom layer is a cross between a biscuit and a cookie. It needs to be able to handle the top gooey layer of butter and cream cheese then double dusted in powdered sugar!
$27.00

Nana's Italian Almond Ricotta cake
A lighter version of a NY style cheesecake this is my Nana's recipe for a traditional almond Italian cheesecake. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$35.00

Old-fashioned Spice Cake
Pennsylvania Dutch country brought to Grandma's Florida kitchen complete with cinnamon and a pinch of nutmeg.
$27.00

Sugar Crunch Cakes
$27.00


Cookies
choose from a variety of cookie options for your holiday dessert table
Baker's dozen box
13 cookies of your choosing
$15.50

two dozen box
24 cookies of your choosing or choose assorted and let us give you a wide variety of cookies.
$28.00

Medium Tray
3 dozen cookies of your choice
$45.00

Large Tray
4 dozen cookies of your choice
$55.00

Extra Large Tray
5 dozen cookies of your choice
$65.00

Christmas Pre-Order: Pick-ups will be 12/21-12/24
October 1st - December 17th. However, depending on how many pre-orders we receive, we might need to close the menu early.

Pies
Key Lime Pie
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a traditional graham cracker crust and the key lime custard pie, we add a special touch, an extra layer of key lime mousse! Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$30.00

Apple Pie
$30.00

Chocolate Pie
$30.00

Cannoli Pie
MUST HAVE 2 DAY LEAD TIME
$30.00

Pumpkin Pie
$30.00

Cherry Pie
$30.00

Cheesecakes
Fireball Eggnog
Baked with a Nilla Wafer crust and Fireball Eggnog, topped with our Holiday Eggnog cookie crumbles, whipped cream, and a pinch of nutmeg. MUST HAVE A 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Our cheesecakes are baked special to order just for you!
$55.00

Death by Chocolate
a chocolate cookie crust with chocolate cheesecake and a chocolate ganache and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$54.00

Spiced Gingerbread
Baked with a shortbread and molasses cookie crust, warm spices, quality molasses, topped with whipped cream and our gingerbread cookie crumbs. MUST HAVE A 3 DAY LEAD TIME. We bake our cheesecakes to order just for you!
$53.00

Heavenly Holiday Cheesecake
Baked with a pistachio spice infused maple syrup graham cracker crust with a white chocolate cranberry cheesecake topped with whipped cream, sugared cranberries and chopped pistachios
$60.00

RumChata Snickerdoodle
Baked with a snickerdoodle and graham cracker crust, RumChata, cinnamon spice, topped with whipped cream and snickerdoodle cookie crumbs. MUST HAVE A 3 DAY LEAD TIME. We bake our cheesecakes to order, special just for you!
$55.00

Pumpkin Cheesecake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a Biscoff cookie crust, a pumpkin cheesecake and topped with whipped cream and more crushed Biscoff cookie crumbs! Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.
$52.00


Cakes
Amish Dutch Apple Cake
9x13 cake covered in cinnamon apples
$30.00

Sugar Crunch Cakes
$27.00

Butter Cake
MUST HAVE AT LEAST 2 DAY LEAD TIME. Missouri Ooey Gooey Butter Cake that is simply to die for! The bottom layer is a cross between a biscuit and a cookie. It needs to be able to handle the top gooey layer of butter and cream cheese then double dusted in powdered sugar!
$27.00

Old-fashioned Spice Cake
Pennsylvania Dutch country brought to Grandma's Florida kitchen complete with cinnamon and a pinch of nutmeg.
$27.00

Pumpkin Crumb Cake
A perfectly spiced pumpkin cake covered in a slightly crunchy thick crumb topping, perfect for any holiday table. 9x13
$27.00

Cinnamon Crumb Cake
$27.00

Cookies
Baker's dozen box
13 cookies of your choosing
$15.50

two dozen box
24 cookies of your choosing or choose assorted and let us give you a wide variety of cookies.
$28.00

Medium Tray
3 dozen cookies of your choice
$45.00

Large Tray
4 dozen cookies of your choice
$55.00

Extra Large Tray
5 dozen cookies of your choice
$65.00

.png)