top of page

Pick Up/Delivery Menu

ALL ORDERS CAN ONLY BE PICKED UP AT 107 EAST LADY LAKE BLVD. OR DELIVERED.



PRICE LIST

ALL CHEESECAKES AND PIES MUST BE PREORDERED WITH AT LEAST A 3 DAY LEAD TIME.




Plain Cheesecake

MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Comes with traditional graham cracker crust unless you would like our signature cookie crust. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.

$47.00

Add Signature Cookie Crust

Cookie crust

$2.00
Plain Cheesecake


Cheesecake with fruit

MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with our signature cookie crust and topped with a fruit of your choice. We can also add fruit to the inside of the cheesecake and flavor the cheesecake as well. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.

$52.00

Fruit on the top

blueberry

$1

raspberry

$1

peach

$1
Cheesecake with fruit


Death by Chocolate

MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. A chocolate cookie crust with chocolate cheesecake and a chocolate ganache and sprinkled with mini chocolate chips. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.

$55.00

Death by Chocolate


Peanut Butter

MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. A Nutter Butter cookie crust with a peanut butter cheesecake topped with a peanut butter ganache and crushed Nutter Butter cookies. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance

$57.00

Peanut Butter


Oreo

MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with an Oreo cookie crust and Cookies and Cream flavored cheesecake and bits of Oreos then topped with crushed Oreos. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.

$53.00

Oreo


Baileys'

MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with our Signature cookie crust and Baileys' baked into the cheesecake and topped with a Baileys' glaze and crushed .Biscoff cookies. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.

$60.00

Baileys'


Cannoli

MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. This top-of-the-line gourmet cheesecake is baked with crushed cannoli shells mixed with graham cracker crumbs and our own cannoli filling mixed into the cheesecake batter with mini chocolate chips, then topped with a chocolate ganache and whipped cream and sprinkled with more cannoli shells. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.

$65.00

Cannoli


Pumpkin

MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a Biscoff cookie crust, a pumpkin cheesecake and topped with whipped cream and more crushed Biscoff cookie crumbs! Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.

$52.00

Pumpkin


Nana's Italian Almond Ricotta cake

A lighter version of a NY style cheesecake this is my Nana's recipe for a traditional almond Italian cheesecake. Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.

$35.00

Nana's Italian Almond Ricotta cake


Fruit Filled Italian Ricotta Cake

The same as our Nana's Italian, but instead of almond we add a fruit swirl and more fruit on the top. Baked to order. Must be ordered at least 3 days in advance

$40.00

Ricotta Cake Fruit Flavors

raspberry

blueberry

strawberry

Fruit Filled Italian Ricotta Cake


Key Lime Pie

MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Baked with a traditional graham cracker crust and the key lime custard pie, we add a special touch, an extra layer of key lime mousse! Baked to order and must be ordered at least 3 days in advance.

$30.00

Key Lime Pie


Scones

Perfectly baked and not dry or crumbly. call us to see what flavors we have that week. We change it up every week!

$3.75

Scones


Jumbo Cinnamon Rolls - Saturdays

typically 4" x 3" some vary slightly in size because they are not mass produced. It is the nature of "from scratch". Some rise so high they barely fit in the box, and others don't rise as much. We do our absolute best to try to get them as identical as possible. Then they are topped with our very own butter cream cheese icing and sprinkled with Cinnamon Roll Yum Crumbs!

Regular Cinnamon Roll

$4.50


Caramel Pecan Cinnamon Roll

$5.00

Available Saturday Only
Jumbo Cinnamon Rolls - Saturdays


Muffins

Fluffy Bakery Jumbo style muffins. Check with us weekly for the flavors we are offering. We try to have 3 different flavors at a time.

$3.75

Muffins


Biscotti

(2 for...) check with us each week as we bake different flavors often to mix it up.

$4.25

Biscotti


Spinach Feta Bread

Milk, flour, butter, fresh baby spinach, and feta crumbles! That's it!

$10.50

Spinach Feta Bread


Pepperoni Mozz. Bread

Milk, flour, pepperoni & mozzarella cheese and butter! That's it!

$12.50

Pepperoni Mozz. Bread


Bacon Cheddar Bread

Milk, flour, Bacon and cheddar cheese! That's it!

$11.50

Bacon Cheddar Bread


Ham & Swiss bread

Milk, flour, ham, Swiss, & butter! That's it!

$11.50

Ham & Swiss bread


Baker's dozen box

13 cookies of your choosing

$15.25

Cookie Flavors

assorted (no sugar free)

chocolate chip

chocolate coconut cluster

Baker's dozen box


two dozen box

24 cookies of your choosing or choose assorted and let us give you a wide variety of cookies.

$28.00

Cookie Flavors

assorted (no sugar free)

chocolate chip

chocolate coconut cluster

two dozen box


Brownies

sometimes we add mini chocolate chips to the top

nuts

$3.50


no nuts

$3.50

Brownies


Loaf cake

We have many different flavors that we add often, however you can choose from our usual flavors. If making a special request, please remember that sometimes items are seasonal due to ingredient availability. Also, we must have at least 3 days in order to bake your special request due to our order schedule.

$9.50

Loaf Cake Regular Flavors

BANANA NUT

brown sugar cinnamon streusel

Loaf cake


Pastry Platter

20 items of your choosing all beautifully decorated on one platter. It makes a wonderful gift for the holidays, birthday, anniversary, even a memorial service. Please remember that the flavors of your items must coincide with flavor availability.

$75.00

Pastry Platter Choices

scone

muffin

brownie

Pastry Platter


Pie - whole

MUST HAVE AT LEAST 3 DAY LEAD TIME. Choose from one of our 9" pies baked with homemade from scratch crust just like Grandma used to make. Must be ordered at least 3 days in advance

$30.00

Pie Flavors

apple

chocolate

pumpkin

Pie - whole


Turnovers

We have a variety of flavors, and we usually offer 3 different at a time. Call us to see if we have any. Each one is handcrafted with our own filling mixtures.

$4.00

Turnovers


Butter Cake

Missouri Ooey Gooey Butter Cake that is simply to die for! The bottom layer is a cross between a biscuit and a cookie. It needs to be able to handle the top gooey layer of butter and cream cheese then double dusted in powdered sugar!

whole

$25.00


half

$12.50


Sugar-free (whole only) preorder

$30.00

Butter Cake


Crumb Cake

whole

$25.00


half

$12.50

Crumb Cake Flavors

Cinnamon

lemon

pumpkin

Crumb Cake


Cheesecake slices

Every week we try to offer 1-2 flavors of our cheesecake slices. If ordering online be aware that if you don't call to find out what we have, you may not get the flavor you want.

Cheesecake slices


Key Lime Pie slice

Please call ahead to see if we have any before ordering. Especially during the holiday season we typically will not make them.

$3.75

Key Lime Pie slice


Dog Cookies

Choose between our two flavors of Fur baby cookies. Both are extremely healthy with no preservatives. So clean people can eat them

$2.00

Dog Cookies

Benny Bites

$2.00

Nibbles Nuggets

$2.00
Dog Cookies


Artisan Bread

Jalapeño Cheddar

$7.00

Artisan Bread


English Muffin Bread

Tastes just like an English muffin but this one you can slice for toasting or making a sandwich.

plain

$7.00


cranberry

$8.00

English Muffin Bread


Sourdough

Sourdough must be preordered for specific flavors or please call the shop 352-204-0201, to see what is available. Purchase will be completed in the shop.

Sourdough Flavors

Classic - round

Classic - sandwich

Jalapeño Cheddar

Sourdough


Amish Dutch Apple Cake

A beautifully moist and flavorful cake baked with 9 cinnamon apples and dusted with powdered sugar and drizzled in caramel!

half

$15.00


whole

$30.00

Amish Dutch Apple Cake


Chocolate Torte

A flourless chocolate cake that is a gluten-free friendly option for anyone choosing to limit their gluten intake, but still want to enjoy sweet treats

half

$17.00


whole

$37.00

Chocolate Torte


Extra Large Tray

5 dozen cookies of your choice

$65.00

Flavor choices

assorted (no sugar free)

chocolate chip

oatmeal raisinette

Extra Large Tray


Large Tray

4 dozen cookies of your choice

$55.00

Flavor choices

assorted (no sugar free)

chocolate chip

oatmeal raisinette

Large Tray


Medium Tray

3 dozen cookies of your choice

$45.00

Flavor choices

assorted (no sugar free)

chocolate chip

oatmeal raisinette

Medium Tray


Chocolate Snack Cake

half

$12.50


whole

$25.00


bottom of page